10 Best Cake Icing Smoothers and Scrapers

Best Cake Icing Smoother

"We independently review the products we recommend! When you buy through links on TheLadyChef.com, We may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more"

Being a baker, I understand the importance of the right tools, especially when decorating a cake. Decent and smooth icing is the only thing that gives a special look to your cake. Decorating a cake requires some baking skills; however, with the best Icing Smoother and Scraper, you can make the entire process a breeze.

So whether you are a passionate baker eager to learn cake decoration or a seasoned baker looking to refine your techniques, the best cake icing smoother and scraper can help you achieve your goal. We’ve created a list of these icing scrapers if you want to make the best impression of cake icing and frosting while making a birthday cake, a wedding cake, or an Easter dessert.

Top 10 Cake Icing Smoothers / Scrapers

  1. Best Overal: Wilton Comb Icing Smoother
  2. Best Cake Smoother with Leveler: Youngsome Cake Scraper Smoother
  3. Best Premium: Bleteleh Large Bench
  4. Best Budget: PME Tall Patterned Edge
  5. Best Large Cake Smoother: Restaurantware 19.8 Inch x 2 Inch Cake Comb
  6. Best For Eye-Catching Design: Restaurantware Pastry Tek
  7. Best Stylish: OXO Good Grips Scraper & Chopper
  8. Best Stainless Steel: Fat Daddio’s BS-57 Bench Scraper
  9. Best All-In-One: Ateco Decorating Comb
  10. Best Traditional: PME Stainless Steel Plain Side

Wilton Comb Icing Smoother

Wilton Comb Icing Smoother

What We Like

  • Easy to use
  • Easy to maintain and clean
  • Provide six different patterns to design your frosting
  • The three combs fit adequately to make storage easy

What We Don’t Like

  • Plastic construction
  • Lacks a good feel and control.

From creating cakes to decorating cupcakes for special occasions, Wilton has different tools, accessories, and toppings you’ll need to create a unique art piece. This is one of the best comb icing smoother sets by Wilton, and all of these snap together to make storage easy.

I tested this comb in making a lot of birthday cakes, especially my favorite strawberry coconut cake, summer desserts, and Fall desserts. As per my experience, this 9 in. x 3 in. scraper worked really well, and I made some of the perfect textured patterns while spreading different colors on the cake. This big dimension covers the maximum cake area in one turn.

Though the build quality is not classy, its plastic construction is sturdy enough to stay for a long time in your baking journey. Remember to wash the Wilton comb with soapy water after finishing every cake frosting to increase its life.

As for the downside, the plastic holding is slightly weird because it has the same pattern all over the sides. So, whatever side you hold, the other is pressing against your palm and feels uncomfortable. However, the overall quality is good enough and works well to leave a depression on the frosting.

You can also buy it at Wilton, Walmart

Youngsome Cake Scraper / Smoother

Youngsome Cake Scraper Smoother

What We Like

  • Option to adjust the height.
  • Sturdy and durable design.
  • Create delicate edges.
  • Multi-purpose tool.

What We Don’t Like

  • Sometimes its knob slide down.

If you are looking for an adjustable cake scraper and smoother, the Youngsome’s cake scraper the right choice you can make. The tool lets you frost a cake up to 12 inches; however, you can adjust its height according to your needs to create sharp edges even if you make a square cake.

The thick stainless steel scale ensures its premium that offers hardness, strength, and high-temperature resistance with the promise to last long for the coming years. This Youngsome smoother can be cleaned with a kitchen towel or even tissue paper. Adjust the knob at your required height, put your cake on the stand and keep moving the stand along with the tool, and create smooth and sharp edges. That’s it.

You can use this multipurpose scraper for decorating cakes or cutting pastries. Or, You can use it as a cake knife, bench scraper, food chopper, dough cutter, and chocolate spreader. Cake Scraper Smoother is a great tool to build on your current skills or want to learn something new. So, let’s make your special events more memorable by decorating an eye-catching cake with this tool!

Bleteleh Large Bench Scraper

Bleteleh Large Bench Scraper and cake scraper

What We Like

  • Sturdy build
  • The blade can be sharpened
  • Comfortable grip
  • Large blade

What We Don’t Like

  • Heavy to work with.
  • Not suitable for small wrists.

Bleteleh Large Benchscraper is another its multipurpose scraper that you can use to smooth the cake topping, or as a dough cutter, vegetable or herb chopper, kitchen bench scraper, and more. Bleteleh is 10 inches larger than the other icing smoother on the list, like OXO Good Grip.

Bleteleh Large Bench has high-quality stainless steel construction and is meant to to used for daily use. The best part its handle for a solid grip without hurting your palm like a Wilton comb.

The ergonomic and comfortable grip makes it the best large cake smoothing tool I’ve ever used. At the same time, the other side is sharp to cut dough and other things. So, whether you need a tool for professional or home use, the Bleteleh large bench scraper is one of the most comfortable cake scrapers.

Although it has a sturdy handle and design, it is difficult to hold for short-wrist users due to its large sized grip. Moreover, it may feel slightly heavy while working. However, if you want to smooth the cake top at the higher level of perfection, the Bleteleh Large Bench is your best pick.

You can also buy it at eBay

PME Tall Patterned Edge Side Scrapper

PME Tall Patterned Edge Side Scrapper

What We Like

  • Both edges are useable to give different patterns to the cake.
  • Best to frost taller cakes.
  • Excellent build quality.
  • Easy to use and easy to clean.

What We Don’t Like

  • The pattern edge may feel uncomfortable while holding.

PME Tall Patterned Edge is a cake smoother that helps you make taller textured cakes, especially for decorating wedding cakes and themed parties. It is a 10-inch high and 3.5 inches wide and has optimal dimensions compared to the Restaurantware Pastry. You can create different designs, from smooth textures to strips.

The best thing I experienced with this cake icing smoother is that you can use both edges to make designs. One edge has strips, while the other is smooth. So you can use both sides to make the icing smooth and pattern.

Though the scraper is built with high-quality food grade plastic, it is still not much durable as compared to the stainless steel scrapers. Overall, this cake scraper is excellent for creating all types of cakes. Still, its pattern side may feel uncomfortable while making your frosting smooth from the other edge.

Overall, it is an excellent tool that helps you to make your cake top smooth and perfect for decorating.

You can also buy it at Walmart

Restaurantware 19.8 Inch x 2 Inch Cake Comb

Restaurantware 19.8 Inch x 2 Inch Cake Comb

What We Like

  • Large size, which is perfect for taller cakes.
  • Create thin strips and smooth, thick strips.
  • It is made of scratch-proof and shatterproof design.
  • Stainless steel material makes it durable.

What We Don’t Like

  • Strip design to both ends, making holding difficult.
  • Best for large cakes.

Add gorgeous details with Restaurantware cake comb to your sweet desserts. It has two assorted edges, one edge measures 5 mm wide, and the other one 10 mm. I have tested this cake comb to make a large cake for my themed party and loved its design as I make strips in one turn.

The Restaurantware cake comb lets you makes intricate thick and thin strips depending on the side you use to decorate your cake. Its stainless steel build is sturdy, scratch resistant and shatterproof making it the most durable combs I’ve ever used.

You can use this cake decorating comb for making sweet homemade desserts at your bakery, cake shop, or in your kitchen at home. Make sure to hand wash it after every use if you want to maintain the build quality of this cake comb. So, let’s add a stylish look to your cake for special occasions.

You can also buy it at Restaurantware

Restaurantware Pastry Tek / Cake Scraper

Restaurantware Pastry Tek and Cake Scraper

What We Like

  • It has an eye-catching design.
  • Aluminum construction makes it durable.
  • Easy to use and clean.
  • Space-saving storage.

What We Don’t Like

  • Requires hand wash only.

Restaurantware Pastry Tek is on the list due to its eye-catching design and four assorted edges. You can use it from all sides to make cakes of every size according to your preferences.

The 4 assorted sides of this cake scraper allow you to make different sized strips, and with one side, you can even make the cake top smooth. The 4 sides make it more valuable compared to Restaurantware cake comb and other icing smoothers.

The best thing is that it is shatterproof, scratch-resistant metal promising that it will last longer than other cake combs. Moreover, its compact design with a hanging hole makes storage easy in a suitable location.

The cake comb is best for large and small cakes and other desserts at the cake shop, home, or bakery. With its dimensions of 6 inches long and 3.8 inches wide, it is the perfect and best cake frosting for decorating any cake. So, let’s create a beautiful cake and make your event enjoyable.

OXO Good Grips Scraper & Chopper

OXO Good Grips Scraper & Chopper

What We Like

  • Great quality.
  • Excellent handle for good grip.
  • Multi-purpose tool.
  • Easy to clean

What We Don’t Like

  • It may get rusted with time.

Are you looking for something great for your baking passion? Then OXO Good Grip is one of the best cake smoother to satisfy your needs. You can use OXO cake comb to make topping smooth or to give a textured look. Just like Bleteleh bench scraper, you can use it for chopping veggies, cutting dough, scraping baking sheets, scraping baking, and more.

Though it has stainless steel build, it is prone to rust if not maintained properly. What I liked the most was the measurement marking on the blade, which is not available on the Ateco, and Bleteleh decorative cake decorating scrapers. So, you can use it as a scraper, a ruler, or even as a cutter.

The plastic built handle offers a strong grip that provides an extra level of comfort while glazing the cake with frosting or icing. It is also tall enough to keep your hands away from food to avoid clutter.

The cleaning is very easy as it is dishwasher safe. No more hand cleaning is required after using it. You will love OXO Good Grips as it is a scraper, ruler, and blade. So add it to your baking tools to take advantage of the many features. Done

You can also buy it at Target, OXO

Fat Daddio’s BS-57 Bench Scraper

Fat Daddio's BS-57 Bench Scraper

What We Like

  • Perfect for turning and lifting dough
  • Scrap the surface to clean it
  • Comfortable handle
  • Dishwasher safe

What We Don’t Like

  • Require maintenance to avoid rusting

Fat Daddio’s Bench Scraper is the best cake-smoothing tool for multiple tasks. It will prove a workhorse for your kitchen as you can turn and lift the dough perfectly from the surface, chop soft items, and scrap the working surface to clean it properly.

It has the blade dimensions 7 1/4″ x 5″ (18.4 x 12.7 cm), 7″ x 3.5″ (17.8 x 8.9 cm). The best thing is that it has two measurement options: inches on the front and cm on the back. These measurements help you to cut the food items perfectly in size.

You can smooth your cake top and create sharp edges by removing and spreading extra frosting. Moreover, the build quality is also high-end. The stainless steel blade makes it durable, and the ABS plastic handle ensures a secure and easy grip without hurting your hand and wrist.

You can easily store it in your kitchen cabinet as its blade will not hurt you. Clean Fat Daddios properly after every use to avoid rusting. It is easy to clean with hands but also dishwasher safe.

You can also buy it at Walmart, Fat Daddio’s

Ateco Decorating Comb 

Ateco Decorating Comb

What We Like

  • Durable build.
  • It has four sides to create designs.
  • Easy to use.
  • Easy to clean.

What We Don’t Like

  • Sharp three edges may feel uncomfortable while holding.

Ateco Decorating Comb is a metal that helps you make the best cake frosting smoother. Its four sides have a design to give your cake the best pattern. Three sides of the icing have splitters, while one side is smooth. You can use any side according to your need and cake design.

You may only need to apply thick layers of icing to your cake, dip the smoother into hot water, then shake excess water and move it along the icing surface. If you hold it at an angle, you may remove less icing and give your cake top smooth and a perfect texture.

The smoother cack’s two long sides help you handle large cakes. At the same time, the other two small sides may help you to design small cakes. Its meta build is durable and will last long if you maintain it.

It is easy to handle from the smoother side. But if you hold it from the side with splitters, it may feel uncomfortable on your palm. However, the quality is good enough and gives you the best results with an easy-to-clean, easy-to-store, easy-to-use, and durable build.

You can also buy it at PastryDepot, eBay, Walmart

PME Stainless Steel Plain Side

PME Stainless Steel Plain Side Cake Smoother Scrapper

What We Like

  • Smooth and sleek design.
  • Sturdy build.
  • Easy to clean.
  • Rustproof and shatterproof quality.

What We Don’t Like

  • It has a single design.

PME Stainless Steel Plain Side is the best cake-smoothing tool that lasts long. Its simple design and plain edges from both sides give a textured look, and the cake top is smooth. The best thing is that you can easily handle it without feeling uncomfortable.

It is 10 inches large and best for both small and large cakes. But it has a special build to create tall cakes. So, if you want a smoother cake frosting, you can consider adding PME Stainless Steel to your baking gadgets.

It is a stainless steel cake scraper that will last long as it is rust-resistant and shatterproof. But it doesn’t add a splitter to your cake, as both edges are smooth. So, if you prefer a smooth design, it is the best cake-smoothing tool.

You can also buy it at eBay

Frequently asked questions

What makes a cake smoother?

A cake smoother helps you to create sharp and perfect edges of the cake. You can easily shape your cake and set the icing. It is an important tool for icing and can be used on sides, edges, and tops to decorate your cakes.

How much is cake smoother?

The cake smoothers are available in different ranges. The price of cake smoother may vary depending on factors such as build quality, design, and size. So it is up to your preferences and also depends on your budget.

How to use a cake smoother?

It is easy to use the tool. You may only need to place your cake on a stand and move the cake holder by setting the cake smother along with the edges. When you move your cake, the tool will remove the extra icing and give your cake a smooth texture or design according to your needs.

What can I use instead of a cake smoother?

You can use a flat spatula instead of a cake smoother. A spatula can help you to set the frosting on your cake. But a cake smoother or scraper is more efficient and comfortable. They are not too expensive, so you can spend some bucks to make your cake beautiful.

Hello!! My name is Adalynn I love to eat, travel, and eat some more! I am married to the man of my dreams and have a beautiful little girl whose smiles can brighten anyone’s day!