10 Best Cast Iron Grill Pan Reviews in 2021 – Top Picks

If you don’t have enough space in your backyard or the weather is too chilly for your liking to step out and eat, I can understand your frustration. But that doesn’t mean you don’t deserve a wholesome meal. For that very reason, you should be searching for the best cast iron grill pan, which will provide you with a piping hot fancy meal indoors, in your house’s comfort. How lovely right?

This way, the cast iron grill pan will provide you with flavorful meals and keep your health intact through pre-seasoned pans, so you don’t have to use excess butter or oil.

Additionally, suppose you like your food to have beautiful grill marks on it. In that case, you consider investing in an affordable and also the best cast iron grill pan with the press, a flat surface pan on which you’ll be able to cook whatever your heart desires.

To help you choose the ideal cast iron grill pan, we have some excellent performing cast iron grill pans. Also, our buying guide will aid you in picking the best option out there.

Top 10 Best Cast Iron Grill Reviews in 2021

No.Best Cast Iron GrillsMaterialWeightDimensions
1Cuisinart Square PanCast iron5 pounds15.94″ x10.19″ x3.42″
2Lodge Pre-Seasoned PanCast iron6.5 pounds17.25″ x10.5″ x2.63″
3Gotham Steel Non-Stick PanCast iron1.45 pounds18.3″ x10.75″ x1.5″
4Gourmex ToughpanCast Aluminum2.25 pounds11.02″ x11.02″ x1.57″
5Lodge Pre-Seasoned GrillCast iron3.35 pounds20″ x10.5″ x0.81″
6Le Creuset GrillCast iron7 lbs.13.9″ x15.1″ x2.6″
7NutriChef Reversible Grill PlateCast iron9.33 pounds18″ x10″ x0.6″
8Jim Beam Pre-Seasoned SkilletCast iron3.24 pounds15.5″ x9.5″ x2
9Victoria Grill PanCast iron5.8 pounds18″ x10.75″ x2.75″
10Outset Shrimp PanCast iron5.5 pounds6.25″ x13.25″ x2″

1. Cuisinart 9.25″ Square Grill Pan – Best Overall

Cuisinart 9.25 inch Square Grill Pan

Specifications

  • Model: CI30-23BG
  • Material: Cast Iron
  • Color: Enameled Provencial Blue
  • Weight: 5 pounds
  • Dimensions: 15.94” x 10.19” x 3.42”
  • Brand: Cuisinart

Here we go with our exclusive top pick, the Cuisinart square cast iron grill pan, which rightfully deserves to be on top of our list. Its 9.25 inches grilling pan is well-known for having the best cooking performance once given enough time to heat up.

You won’t be disappointed by the Cuisinart Grill pan, but you’ll need to learn a few tips and tricks first. Setting the flame on medium-high will get the best results as the cast iron grill heats up pretty well. Due to the cast iron contraction, the cast iron grill also retains heat for a long duration.

Cuisinart has introduced an excellent porcelain enameled interior to grab more attention, which is ideal for cooking as it provides equal heat distribution. It can also be placed on any surface, and that wouldn’t have any negative impact or funny odors on the food.

The broad cast iron grill handle is no less than a lifesaver. It is strong, durable, and provides the perfect firm grip when you’re cooking or serving piping hot food. We must say this is one of the best indoor grill pan cast iron enamel coated; we’ve come across it as it does not require detailed cleaning, can be washed in a dishwasher, and is perfect for indoor grilling events.

Pros
  • Retains heat well
  • Firm handle
  • Oven safe
  • Easy to clean
Cons
  • A bit heavy

2. Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Grill Pan – Best Design

Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Grill Pan With Assist Handle

Specifications

  • Model: Pre-seasoned cast iron
  • Material: Cast Iron
  • Color: Black
  • Weight: 6.5 pounds
  • Dimensions: 17.25” x 10.5” x 2.63”
  • Brand: Lodge
  • Diameter: 10.5 inches

Are you craving a juicy burger or a steak but don’t have enough energy to step outside? Don’t worry, as Lodge Pre-seasoned cast iron grill pan has got you covered. You can now grill indoors with it. And do you know what the best part about this cast iron grill is? It is already pre-seasoned, which means you can start grilling your food right away without any delay.

This pre-seasoned cast iron grill pan can be used on all cooking surfaces without worrying, as the high edges on the sides protect your countertops from unwanted splashes of food. To score points for food presentation, the interior’s ridges leave beautiful grill marks on your food.

With a heavy-duty design, the square grill pan ensures equal heat distribution and has a durable and long-lasting built. The cast-iron pan can be used in two ways you can place it on the stove as well as in the oven if you’re having cravings for a baked stake. Not only that, but we can say that this is one of the best-shaped square cast iron grills pans as it can easily accommodate more food, such as two decent-sized pieces of stake for you and your partner.

Pros
  • Is pre-seasoned
  • Oven safe
  • Easy-grip handle
  • Light on the pocket
Cons
  • Weighs too much

3. Gotham Steel Nonstick Grill Pan – Best Eco-Friendly

Gotham Steel Nonstick Grill Pan for Stovetops with Grill Sear Ridges

Specifications

  • Model: Gotham steel
  • Material: Cast Iron
  • Color: Brown
  • Weight: 1.45 pounds
  • Dimensions: 18.3” x 10.75” x 1.5”
  • Brand: Gotham
  • Diameter: 10.5 inches

Gotham is amongst the well-known manufacturers of ceramic coated cookware and claims to have the best cast iron grill pans in the market. With an ultra-non-stick coating done three times and reinforced with diamonds, this grilling pan promises to deliver the ultimate food. 

The ridges on the non-stick pan’s sides are perfect for grilling burgers, steaks, and chicken, while the bottom of the ridges leaves aesthetic grill marks on the food. Moreover, these high ridges are useful for reducing hot food splatters on the counters. To earn more brownie points, the eco-friendly Gotham cast iron grill pan is coated with minerals, making sure that the food is healthy and non-toxic while allowing the extra liquids and fats to slip away, making the meal healthy and fat-free.

Moreover, the coating of the cast iron grill pan is durable and robust enough to withstand the use of metal utensils such as spoons, spatulas, whisk, and surprisingly even electric beaters. The stainless steel handle provides relief when cooking or serving hot food as it remains cool throughout. Last but not least – the part we all dread the most. Yes, the washing. It is entirely effortless and hassle-free to do.

Pros
  • Ultra-durable coating
  • Drains grease easily
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Handle stays cool
Cons
  • No color variety

4. GOURMEX Toughpan Induction Grill Pan – Best Material

GOURMEX Toughpan Induction Grill Pan

Specifications

  • Model: Gourmex toughpan
  • Material: Cast Aluminum
  • Color: Black
  • Weight: 2.25 pounds
  • Dimensions: 11.02” x 11.02” x 1.57”
  • Brand: Gourmex
  • Diameter: 11 inches

Just as the name suggests, the Gourmex toughpan induction grill pan indeed lives up to its name because it is constructed from heavy-duty cast aluminum material, making it strong, durable, and ever-lasting. The heavy cast aluminum is useful for delivering heat quickly and efficiently all over the grill pan during cooking.

Additionally, the cast iron grill pan’s body is covered with a non-stick coating, ensuring that the pan is safe from the slightest of scratches even after prolonged use. Its handle is made from stainless steel and is covered with black silicone, which amazingly is heat resistant.

Gourmex toughpan not only works with induction stoves but is also highly compatible with high-tech cooktops. It doesn’t matter whether you cook on gas, electricity, or even coal, as this aluminum grill pan has been specially made to withstand all heat sources.

Washing this gourmex grill pan is a no-brainer. All you have to do is clean it with soapy water, rinse it thoroughly and let it dry. Moreover, you can also use any scrubber to scrub off the grease and oil remains which hardly ever happens as the grill pan is non-stick. Besides being durable, this is one of the best cast iron grills as it is ecological, safe to use, and 100% chemical-free.

Pros
  • High-quality material
  • Eco-friendly
  • Durable material
  • Caters various foods
Cons
  • No covering lid

5. Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Grill – Best Heating

Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Grill Pan With Assist Handle

Specifications

  • Model: Lodge Pre-seasoned
  • Material: Cast Iron
  • Color: Black
  • Weight: 3.35 lbs.
  • Dimensions: 20” x 10.5” x 0.81”
  • Brand: Lodge
  • Diameter: 20 inches

The Lodge pre-seasoned cast iron grill has a unique two-in-one feature as it can be used as both a griddle and a cast iron grill. Do you know what the most convenient part is? It is pre-seasoned and ready to use as soon as you purchase it. Also, the non-stick qualities further add to the performance and improve the taste of the food.

The pre-seasoned cast iron grill has an excellent heating capacity, ensuring that the heat spreads equally across the grill and is prepped evenly. The best feature is that even after turning off the heat, the cast iron grill remains hot for a long time, so imagine how hot the food will be?

Needless to say that it might be the best cast iron grill pan for steak as it is spacious and a good option, especially for large families when they want to cook steaks on the stove when they can’t step outside. Let me tell you that the 20 x 10.5 inch griddle collects juice in one part so that the steak can be cooked properly without steaming. But that’s not all. This flat cast iron grill can easily fit anywhere, whether it’s the stove or oven in the kitchen or even a campfire in the woods.

Pros
  • More cooking space
  • Completely oven safe
  • Includes Safety handles
  • For various surfaces
Cons
  • Sides are not high

6. Le Creuset Enameled Cast Iron Grill – Best Enamel

Le Creuset Enameled Cast Iron Signature Square Skillet Grill

Specifications

  • Model: LS2021-2667
  • Material: Cast Iron
  • Color: Cerise
  • Weight: 7 lbs.
  • Dimensions: 13.9” x 15.1” x 2.6”
  • Brand: Le Creuset
  • Diameter: 10.25 inches

Le Creuset is a famous name when it comes to its enameled cast iron grill pans. These pans are appreciated for their craftsmanship and style and are considered one of the best markets. This Le Creuset cast iron grill pan can’t miss being a part of your kitchen with its glossy exterior and bright color.

Being the rare brand that everyone says, this Le Creuset cast iron grill pan is made of an even-heating enameled cast iron interior that provides an equal amount of heat to the food being cooked. The ridges on the inside leave aesthetic grill marks on the food and encourage low-fat cooking.

The cast iron grill pan’s striking cerise color is long-lasting, resists chipping and cracking if used with care and caution. The cast iron grill pan can be washed by hand as well in the entirely safe dishwasher. You don’t need to worry about the enamel chipping off or the grill pan getting any cracks on it.

What’s the verdict? We believe it is safe to say that Le Creuset Enameled iron cast grill might be the best cast iron grill skillet for homes as it is dishwasher safe, long-lasting, and a wise choice for smaller families.

Pros
  • Superior heat distribution
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Strong iron handle
  • Low-fat cooking
Cons
  • Very expensive

7. NutriChef Cast Iron Reversible Grill Plate – Best Reversible

NutriChef Cast Iron Reversible Grill Plate

Specifications

  • Model: 18-inch flat cast iron skillet
  • Material: Iron
  • Color: Induction, Ceramic
  • Weight: 9.33 pounds.
  • Dimensions: 18” x 10” x 0.6”
  • Brand: NutriChef
  • Diameter: 18 inches

Are you searching for a cast iron grill pan that is large as you have a huge family to serve? Are you tired of cooking food in 2 to 3 turns? If your answer is yes, then we’re here with a solution for you. The NutriChef cast iron reversible grill plate caters you to a 2 –1 design, which means more variety and less spending for you.

Do you know what the most convenient part is? This can be the best cast iron grill pan to cook burgers or steak on the ribbed side, while you can quickly cook eggs, sandwiches, and pancakes on the other side, which is the flatter one. The cast iron reversible grill has a non-stick surface which ensures that food is released with ease and is healthy as it eliminates the need for butter or oil.

Furthermore, the cast iron skillet works best with stovetops, is oven safe up to 480F, and compatible with heating methods such as gas, ceramic, and electric stoves. The NutriChef iron grill pan is easy to clean and is stain-resistant. Additional accessories include silicone mittens which are perfect for handling the skillet when it comes out of the oven.

Pros
  • Well designed
  • Two in one use
  • Protective mitts given
  • Large in size
Cons
  • No handles on the side

8. Jim Beam Pre Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet – Best Price

Jim Beam JB0159 Pre Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet

Specifications

  • Model: JB0159
  • Material:  Iron
  • Color: Black  
  • Weight: 3.24 pounds.
  • Dimensions: 15.5” x 9.5” x 2”
  • Brand: Jim Beam  
  • Diameter: 11.8  inches

Let’s say not everybody likes frying pans; some need pre-seasoned skillets too. So, here’s another option for you, a pre-seasoned cast iron skillet by Jim Beam, which has already made its name in the market as it offers a blend of affordability and practicality side by side.

When we talk about the cast iron skillet’s surface, it has a perfectly ridged surface that ensures healthy, low-calorie eating as it drains away extra oils and fats. Not only that, but it also leaves perfect grilling marks on the food for you to enjoy. It is ideal for preparing various meals like hamburgers, sandwiches, steak, or even fish.

The Jim Beam Skillet is no less than a masterpiece as it boasts of being one of the best cast iron grill pans under $30 currently due to the fantastic features it offers at such an affordable price. These features include an even heat system and incredible durability, and less wear and tear over the years to come.

Furthermore, the cast iron skillet is non-stick and avoids potentially harmful substances for people who season it and use it regularly. Also, uncoated cast iron tends to leach small amounts of iron into food as it cooks, which I must say is a unique health benefit.

Pros
  • Strong wooden base
  • No harmful substances used
  • Is highly durable
  • Is budget-friendly
Cons
  • No color options

9. Victoria Cast Iron Grill Pan – Best Versatile

Victoria Cast Iron Grill Pan

Specifications

  • Model: Cast iron grill pan
  • Material: Cast Iron
  • Color: Black 
  • Weight: 5.8 pounds.
  • Dimensions: 18” x 10.75” x 2.75”
  • Brand: Victoria
  • Diameter: 12 inches

Victoria’s 12-inch cast iron skillet has earned a spot on our list due to its straightforward and dependable nature. It has been pre-seasoned with flaxseed oil which promotes healthy eating. Additionally, It is also recommended by many experts as it has higher sides, a curved removable handle, and a wide diameter.

This Victoria cast iron grill pan’s performance surely deserves appreciation as it ensures the heat is spread evenly during the cooking process. The pan stays hot even after the stove is turned off, and the food remains warm throughout this time. The food is healthy and tasty because it is ensured that no harmful substances such as PTFE and PFOA’s are used during the coating.

Surprisingly, traces of iron are released into the food while cooking as supposedly iron is healthy for you and healthily boosts your diet. Now, what’s so versatile about this iron grill pan? This is one of the best cast iron grills for stove tops but not only limited to stovetops.It can also be used as a campfire, vegetable, Panini, and bbq grill pan.

Moreover, unlike other cast iron grills, this Victoria pan offers you a lifetime warranty without additional costs. Sounds great, right?

Pros
  • Has lifetime warranty
  • Ready-to-use seasoning
  • Promotes healthy eating
  • No harmful substances
Cons
  • Small in size

10. Outset Shrimp Cast Iron Grill Pan – Best Cleaning

Outset 76375 Shrimp Cast Iron Grill and Serving Pan

Specifications

  • Model: Shrimp Grill pan
  • Material: Cast Iron
  • Color: Black 
  • Weight: 5.5 pounds.
  • Dimensions: 6.25” x 13.25” x 2”
  • Brand: Outset

There is no doubt about Outset’s ability to manufacture high-end cast iron grill pans in terms of innovation and versatility. This Outset grill cast iron pan is a dream come true for your unlimited servings of shrimps during important events and family dinners.

Let’s first talk about the multiple functions this cast iron grill pan claims to offer. It is suitable for many different cooking methods, such as frying, baking, cooking, sautéing, and the list just goes on. Also specially made for shrimps, it makes an excellent food presentation, and the food is healthy and free from excess fats and oil.

You may ask how? Let me tell you. Already pre-seasoned from before, the grilling pan does not require additional oils or butter as it encourages healthy eating. The pan’s non-stick surface provides more flavor, texture, proper grilling to the food and ensures that the food slides out with ease.  

We mustn’t forget that besides all of these features, the cast iron grill offers heavy-duty heat, and due to its small size, it can be transferred anywhere from cooktops and ovens to your camping trips. Do you know what the easiest and best way to clean cast iron grill pan is? Hand wash it with warm water, then scrub and rinse it thoroughly, and let the pan dry.

Pros
  • Heavy-duty heat
  • Multi-functional
  • Vast space area
  • Easily washable
Cons
  • Used for particular foods

Cast iron grill pan grooves vs no grooves

Cast iron grill pan with grooves

Are you a huge food lover who likes to have meals that are fulfilling and delicious? Or do you like your proteins? If yes, then using a cast iron grill pan with grooves will help you prepare your favorite foods, including meat, such as steaks, sausages, and hamburgers. Preparing meat in such a pan makes the meat tender and juicy as the liquid runs off from the side.

Not only that, but the ridges will also help to keep the food healthy, fat-free,  and away from any chemical substances as the cast iron grill pan is pre-seasoned beforehand, so there is no need for excess oil and butter. The ridges also leave beautiful grill marks on your food when it is done.

However, it can be challenging to wash iron grill pans with grooves as they require extra care, and delicate foods such as fish and vegetables cannot be cooked in them.

Cast iron grill pan without grooves

If you’re into wholesome, dry and simple meals and not exotic fancy ones, then you should opt for a cast iron grill pan without grooves or a flat surface. These foods can include eggs, pancakes, biscuits, cornbread, or casseroles. Moreover, these pans are also easier to use and do not require practice or any professional experience.

Conveniently, the food has no chance of getting stuck in the ridges or breaking apart as the surface is entirely flat. It also toasts food evenly, unlike pans with grooves, and the final result of the food is almost the same as an iron grill pan with ridges.

On the other hand, the flat surface is bland; it does not create unique designs like a cast iron groove pan and doesn’t have high sides, making food splatters unavoidable.

Best Cast Iron Grill Reviews – The Ultimate Buying Guide

Have you seen Cuisinart has made its mark by offering a grill pan that has it all from the material, color, and coating to the affordable pricing? But are you satisfied with the lodge pre-seasoned grill pan, which has the best modern design available in the market?

And what about the eco-friendly features Gotham offers without any additional costs? With various varieties and competition between different brands, choosing the best cast iron pan for grill can become quite tricky. 

What’s the verdict? There’s no need to fret. You won’t have a hard time figuring out when you finally have to choose the perfect cast iron grill after reading our detailed buying guide we have written just for you.

Grill size

If you’re tired of repeatedly cooking on the same small grill due to a large family or during parties, you should opt for a larger grill pan that doesn’t take up much of your time. However, if you have a small family or are single, then a small-sized cast iron grill pan measuring around 9-10 inches will also do the job.

Material

Have you ever wondered that your grill pan should be suitable for the equipment you have at home? Are you looking for an affordable and best cast iron grill pan for electric stove? If yes, you’ll be glad to know that all cast iron grill pans mentioned above are compatible with electric stoves and gas ones.

With or without ridges

The ridges in a cast iron grill pan depend on what you eat more. If you’re a fan of having meaty foods more often, like hamburgers or steaks, I’d suggest you go for a pan with ridges as it collects liquids on one side and leaves the meat soft and tender.

On the other hand, if you consume dry foods such as eggs, pancakes, or biscuits, then a grill pan without ridges will work correctly for you.

Price

Deciding the price range you want to go for is necessary if you’re on a tight budget and only invest a certain amount. If you’re looking for options for cheap cast iron grill pans, there’s no need to worry as we have provided you with plenty of options.

The cast iron grill pan will not only be easy on the pocket but will also be of good quality.

Weight

If you’re looking for an iron cast grill for daily use, you should go for a light-weight one as it could become a nuisance to carry a heavyweight grill pan every day.

But if you’re looking for an option for the best cast iron grill pan flank steak griddle for gas stove or even electric tops, you won’t have to carry the grill pan every day from the stove to the table. Another recommended option is to get your grill pans fixed on countertops so whether they’re light or heavy, it wouldn’t be a nuisance anymore.

Heat source

A good heat source is a must-have if you want your meal to be cooked properly from all sides. Look for a cast iron grill pan that offers an even spread of heat and preferably stays warm even after the heat is turned off. This way, your food can still serve warm food as the grill pan will remain warm for 10-15 minutes after it is removed from the heat source.

Accessories

Most of the cast iron grill pans do not come with accessories, but the ones that do include cute silicone oven mitts for protection. One of the best cast iron grill plates comes with a wooden plate underneath them, which protects the pan’s surface as it is scalding.

Frequently Asked Questions

The Bottom Line

Getting the best cast iron grill pan will improve and aid your cooking and add a flavor to your food while eating healthy without any additional fats. All of the cast iron grills mentioned above offer promising unique features in a budget-friendly range, which you shouldn’t miss out on.

We have detailed our reviews on the top seven picks, but the choice is yours! After considering all the factors, you should choose which grill pan suits you the best.

But wait, here’s our recommendation, the Cuisinart, 9.25″ Square Grill Pan, which is the perfect solution for all your cooking needs. Now, what are you waiting for? Get your cast iron grill pan now.

Leave a Comment