Top 10 Best Steak Pan Reviews 2021

Beautiful sear marks on food are indeed a sight to see as they make food look presentable, appetizing, and enjoyable. The best part is that sear marks are not only limited to steaks, but they also look catchy on vegetables and sandwiches. For this very reason, you should consider buying one of the best pans for making pan fried steak as it will prepare your meals quickly and also add a flawless aesthetic to them.

Additionally, steak pans are ideal for cooking or frying steak as they offer even heat distribution and heat retention, which ensures that your food remains hot for a long time. You don’t even have to use a large quantity of oil as most steak pans are already pre-seasoned or have a non-stick coating that doesn’t require oil.

If you live alone or have a small family, you can check out one of the best round griddle pans for steak, as it will accommodate all your requirements, and you will also be able to cook a variety of dishes in it, including eggs, and pancakes.

To help you choose the ideal steak pan, we have some excellent performing cast iron and aluminum steak pans. Also, if you’re still confused at the end of the review, our buying guide will aid you in picking the best option for a steak pan out there.

Top 10 Best Steak Pan Reviews 2021

No.Best Steak PansMaterialWeightDimensions
1.Lodge Pre-Seasoned SkilletCast Iron5 pounds16.12″ x10.68″ x2″
2.All-Clad BD55 110D518-10 Steel2 pounds18.3”x10.5”x4.5”
3.Le Creuset Enameled SkilletCast Iron6 pounds13″ x14.8″ x3″
4.Rachael Ray Griddle PanHard Anodized Aluminum2 pounds19″ x10.75″ x3.25″
5.Gourmex ToughpanCast Aluminum2.25 pounds11.02″ x11.02″ x1.57″
6.MasterPan Grill PanCast Aluminum4.75 pounds15″ x12.25″ x2.1″
7.Cuisinart Square Grill PanHard Anodized Aluminum2.84 pounds11.6″ x19.5″ x3.95″
8.Calphalon CookwareHard Anodized Aluminum2.75 pounds20″ x11.5″ x1.5″
9.Cooks Hard Square Grill PanHard Anodized Aluminum2.50 pounds19″ x11″ x1.5″
10.Le Creuset Enameled Cast Iron PanCast Iron4.2 pounds10.5″ x15.3″ x1.6″

1. Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet – Best Overall

Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet With Assist Handle

Specifications

  • Model: Pre-seasoned Cast iron
  • Material: Cast Iron
  • Color: Black
  • Weight: 5 pounds
  • Dimensions: 16.12” x 10.68” x 2”
  • Brand: Lodge
  • Diameter: 10.25 inches

Here we go with our top exclusive pick, the Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet, which rightfully deserves to be on the top of our list due to its unparalleled cooking ability. With a diameter of 10.25 inches, it is an easy-to-use steak pan for all individuals.

If you love to cook your steaks evenly, you will like this pre-seasoned steak pan as the cast iron built ensures even heating while cooking so that no parts of the steak are left uncooked or cold. Moreover, this Lodge pan also retains heat, which means that your food will remain hot and fresh even after turning off the heat.

The assist black handle, which has a firm non-slip grip on the side of the steak pan, gives you easier access while dishing out hot food or taking out freshly baked food from the oven. This steak is not only limited to the stove but can also be used to cook food in the oven, over the campfire, and on the outdoor grill.

We must say that this is the best grill pan for steak we’ve across as it provides multiple uses such as sautéing, frying, and grilling food, has been pre-seasoned with vegetable oil, and works great with induction cooktops.

Pros
  • Firm handle
  • Multiple uses
  • Healthy Pre-seasoning
  • Retains heat
Cons
  • A bit heavy

You may also like:

2. All-Clad BD55110 D5 – Best Design

All-Clad BD55110 D5 Dishwasher Safe Fry Pan

Specifications

  • Model: BD55110 D5
  • Material: 18-10 Steel
  • Color: Stainless Steel
  • Weight: 2 pounds
  • Dimensions: 18.3” x 10.5” x 4.5”
  • Brand: All Clad
  • Diameter: 10 inches

Are you craving a juicy steak for lunch but don’t have the energy to step outdoors and setup the grilling pan. You don’t need to fret as All-Clad BD55110D5 has got your back. With a heavy-duty design, this steak pan will help you fulfill all your cravings in the comfort of your home in less amount of time.

This 10-inch steak pan has a spacious, broad flat base and a low-profile shape giving you enough space to place your steak pieces easily without breaking them. The construction of 5-ply has alternate layers of stainless steel, which is ideal for providing even heating throughout the cooking duration.

Being one of the best stainless steel pans for steak, it has a highly polished surface that offers superior stick resistance against food, delivers easy maintenance, and does not react with food. Moreover, the heat-resistant stainless steel handle remains cool throughout, so you can grab the handle with ease while cooking.

The convenient part is that you can use this All-Clad BD55110D5  in multiple ways, including an induction cooktop and broiler. It is also oven-safe up to 600 degrees and is dishwasher safe which means less manual cleaning for you to do.

Pros
  • Wide flat base
  • Highly polished
  • Safe fry pan
  • Oven safe
Cons
  • Limited warranty provided

3. Le Creuset Enameled Cast Iron Skillet – Best Versatile

Le Creuset Enameled Cast Iron Signature Iron Handle Skillet

Specifications

  • Model: LS2024-2659
  • Material: Cast Iron
  • Color: Marseille
  • Weight: 6 pounds
  • Dimensions: 13” x 14.8” x 3”
  • Brand: Le Creuset
  • Diameter: 10.25 inches

Le Creuset is a well-known name when it comes to cast iron steak pans. Le Creuset pans deserve appreciation for their versatility, and you can cook or bake almost anything in them, including pizzas, vegetables, and of course, steaks. With a striking Marseille color this steak pan is a must-have accessory to brighten up your kitchen.

If you’re diet conscious and like eating healthy foods, unlike other cast iron steak pans, this Le Creuset will make an excellent choice as it is a premium choice for low-fat cooking and requires very little oil. An optimized enamel interior provides improved and steady heating while you cook, and the enamel reduces wear and tear, dulling as well as staining provided that you use the steak pan with care and caution.

The large loop handle on one side of the steak pan facilitates you when lifting the hot pan or serving food to your family members. To ensure a firm and strong grip on the handle, you can even wear oven mitts, keeping your hands safe from the hot steak pan.

What’s the verdict? We must say that this Le Creuset Iron Handle Skillet might be the best pan to use for steak as it provides a convenient cleanup, is dishwasher safe, and provides superior heat retention.

Pros
  • Striking color
  • Requires less oil
  • Provides steady heat
  • Large loop handle
Cons
  • Quite expensive

4. Rachael Ray Griddle Pan – Best Grill Marks

Rachael Ray Brights Hard Anodized Nonstick Square Griddle Pan

Specifications

  • Model: Brights
  • Material: Hard Anodized Aluminum
  • Color: Gray with orange handles
  • Weight: 2 pounds
  • Dimensions: 19” x 10.75” x 3.25”
  • Brand: Rachael Ray
  • Diameter: 11 inches

Are you searching for a steak pan that has ridges on the interior? Do you love it if your food has aesthetic grill marks on it? If the answer to these questions is yes, then we’re here with a solution for you. The Rachael Ray Steak pan not only acts as a perfect replacement for an indoor grill but also provides a remarkable cooking experience.

Do you know why this is the most suitable and best pan for cooking steak? It includes a durable hard-anodized non-stick material that provides fast and easy heating along with raised ridges to give you an authentic steak taste. The high-quality non-stick slides down the food quickly without any effort or having to scrap it off.

Furthermore, the double-riveted orange handle covered with silicone does the trick and makes it easier to move around the kitchen as it has a firm non-slip grip. The Rachael Ray steak pan is exceptionally durable and heats food quickly and evenly without leaving any cold spots on the food.

Washing up this steak pan is one of the easiest things to do, as all you have to do is either wash it manually with soap or put it in the dishwasher for a quick cleanup.

Pros
  • Highly affordable
  • Beautiful grill marks
  • Lifetime warranty
  • High-quality non-stick
Cons
  • Small handle

5. GOURMEX Toughpan Induction Grill Pan – Best Material

GOURMEX Toughpan Induction Grill Pan

Specifications

  • Model: Toughpan
  • Material: Cast Aluminum
  • Color: Black
  • Weight: 2.25 pounds
  • Dimensions: 11.02” x 11.02” x 1.57”
  • Brand: Gourmex  
  • Diameter: 11 inches

Are you looking for a steak pan that is highly durable, safe to use, and also of the best quality? Here’s Gourmex Toughpan, and just as the name suggests, this steak pan has been constructed from heavy-duty cast aluminum material to make sure it sticks around your kitchen for a long time.

The steak pan’s body has been covered with a non-stick and an anti-scratch coating to ensure that no scratch marks from spoons ruin the steak pan’s interior. Due to this coating, it is possible that the steak pan will not rust or warp even after daily cooking. It is the best pan for frying steak as well as chicken, vegetables, and fish. The coating ensures that the steak is perfectly grilled without sticking or burning.

It is also compatible with all heat sources, so whether you cook on gas, electricity, or coal, there is nothing that this Gourmex Toughpan can’t handle. Similar to a restaurant skillet, this steak pan is 100% chemical-free and prioritizes your safety above everything else.

Washing this Induction grill pan doesn’t require great effort as you have to rinse it thoroughly, apply soap, and then dry it off. How simple is that, right?

Pros
  • High-quality material
  • Multiple uses
  • Free from chemicals
  • Fast and easy care
Cons
  • No lid for covering

6. MasterPan Non-Stick Grill Pan – Best Coating

MasterPan Non-Stick Stovetop Oven Grill Pan

Specifications

  • Model: Stovetop Oven Grill Pan with Heat-in Steam-out Lid
  • Material: Cast Aluminum
  • Color: Black
  • Weight: 4.75 pounds
  • Dimensions: 15” x 12.25” x 2.1”
  • Brand: MasterPan  
  • Diameter: 12 inches

MasterPan has quite a reputation in the market for being one of the Cast Aluminum pans’ manufacturers and providing the best pan for searing steak. This steak pan has a superior non-stick layer and is also stain resistant. It uses a triple layer of GRANITEC non-stick coating, which is PFOA-free.

The even heat distribution further contributes to the efficient cooking of food on the non-stick surface and leaves no spots on the food cold or uncooked. Additionally, the food comes right off the surface and slides easily on your plate, which makes cooking even more effortless and enjoyable.

The MasterPan Non-Stick grill pan can be utilized for multiple purposes, including stir-frying, sauteing food, and cooking steak according to your preferences. You can place the steak pan on the stove oven, and the steak pan will retain heat inside to create an oven-like feeling so that the food turns out to be hot and crisp along with the steam.

This steak pan also includes broad and low ribs on the interior, leaving behind a beautiful aesthetic on the food and a must-have for good food presentation if you occasionally have friends or family over for lunch or dinner.

Pros
  • Transparent lid
  • Even heat distribution
  • Wide grill ridges
  • Releases steam
Cons
  • Lid is not tight enough

7. Cuisinart Square Grill Pan – Best Eco-Friendly

Cuisinart GG30-20 GreenGourmet Hard-Anodized Nonstick Grill Pan

Specifications

  • Model: GG30-20
  • Material: Hard Anodized Aluminum
  • Color: Black
  • Weight: 2.84 pounds
  • Dimensions: 11.6” x 19.5” x 3.95”
  • Brand: Cuisinart  
  • Diameter: 11 inches

Here’s the Cuisinart Cast Aluminum Square grill pan, which is also a part of our chosen list due to the unique features it offers, unlike other steak pans. This steak pan has been manufactured using 100% recycled materials and has been printed with soy ink full of minerals, which means you’ll get a touch of minerals in your food without paying extra. How cool is that?

The 12-inch steak pan, which is also oven safe, offers superior heat conductivity, resulting in less energy use and even heating to your steak while you cook it. Moreover, the stainless steel handle is also 70% recycled so that it remains cool while you cook and handle the piping hot food.

Cuisinart has also introduced PFOA-free and chemical-free steak pans to score more points, which keep you safe from various diseases, including cancer, development effects, and liver issues. You can easily enjoy your food without a worry, as the Cuisinart steak pan is entirely chemical-free.

We must say that this Cuisinart Square grill pan is the best pan for steak we have come across. It is not only chemical-free but also contributes to healthy eating and an economically friendly environment.

Pros
  • Superior heating
  • Non-stick surface
  • Chemical-free
  • 100% recycled
Cons
  • Edges are not high

8. Calphalon Hard-Anodized Aluminum Cookware – Best Space

Calphalon Contemporary Hard-Anodized Aluminum Nonstick Cookware

Specifications

  • Model: Contemporary
  • Material: Hard Anodized Aluminum
  • Color: Silver/Gray
  • Weight: 2.75 pounds
  • Dimensions: 20” x 11.5” x 1.5”
  • Brand: Calphalon  
  • Diameter: 11 inches

Are you looking for a steak pan that is more spacious and can accommodate more food as you have a large family to feed? Do you want to save your time and energy by only cooking once? Don’t fret as we have got a solution to your problem. The Calphalon steak pan includes the finest quality heavy gauge aluminum, which assures you high durability.

Guess what the most convenient part is? This steak pan’s interior includes three layers of non-stick coating, 2 layers of durability, and a third layer that easily releases the food on your plate without scraping off or the steak breaking into pieces. It can be one of the best pans for steak frying as the non-stick coating means that you hardly have to add any oil to the steak pan as it encourages healthy-eating without any fats.

The deep ridges are worth it as they deliver an authentic taste for your steak, leave beautiful grill marks on the steak, and evenly cook your steak so that it becomes a pretty shade of brown. Not to forget the sturdy stainless steel handle, which has an impressive design that provides a firm non-slip grasp and remains cool while you cook whatever your heart desires.

Pros
  • Heavy-gauge aluminum
  • 2 layer durability
  • Deep ridges
  • Healthier food
Cons
  • Too pricey

9. Cooks Standard Hard Anodize Square Grill Pan – Best Price

Cooks Standard Hard Anodized Nonstick Square Grill Pan

Specifications

  • Model: Cooks Standard
  • Material: Hard Anodized Aluminum
  • Color: Black
  • Weight: 2.50 pounds
  • Dimensions: 19” x 11” x 1.5”
  • Brand: Cooks Standard
  • Diameter: 11 inches

Cook’s 11-inch Square Grill Pan has earned a place on our list due to its straightforward and dependable nature. Cooks has already made a name in the market as it offers a perfect blend of durability and affordable pricing without compromising the quality.

When we talk about the grill pan’s surface, it has a hard anodized surface that is durable, better, and more rigid material than stainless steel, making it long-lasting and sturdy. It is the best griddle for steak with a perfectly ridged surface as it leaves beautiful aesthetic marks adding points for good food presentation. The square grill pan can easily cater to large families due to its big size.

It has one of the finest quality aluminum cores that distribute heat across the food evenly, ensuring that no cold spots remain. Additionally, the non-stick coating makes cleaning very easy it delivers exceptional performance while cooking. You can easily slide out the steak without any effort as it hardly ever sticks on the steak pan.

What’s the verdict? The Cooks Standard Square Grill Pan is an excellent choice as it works perfectly well on gas, electricity, glass, and even ceramic. Moreover, it is dishwasher safe and does not require much cleanup time.

Pros
  • Hard Anodized surface
  • Multiple uses
  • Ideal for large families
  • Even heat distribution
Cons
  • Not induction compatible

10. Le Creuset Enameled Cast Iron – Best  Color

Le Creuset Enameled Cast Iron Skillet

Specifications

  • Model: Signature Iron Handle Skillet
  • Material: Cast Iron
  • Color: Flame
  • Weight: 4.2  pounds
  • Dimensions: 10.5” x 15.3” x 1.6”
  • Brand: Le Creuset  
  • Diameter: 9 inches

There is no doubt about Le Creuset’s ability to manufacture high-end cast iron grill pans for steak in terms of innovation and quality. This Le Creuset cast iron handle skillet is a dream come true for your impeccable cooking experience, and I must say that the striking flame color adds up everything.

This Le Creuset is an excellent choice and one of the best fry pans for steak, promoting healthy eating. The steak pan is famous for low-fat cooking and requires very little oil no matter what you cook. Moreover, it is optimized for steady, even heating while you cook, which means it hardly leaves the food uncooked or any cold spots. The pan makes sure that heat spreads to the entire steak so you can consume it hot and fresh.

The enamel interior is famous as, unlike other cast iron steak pans, it doesn’t require any seasoning or extra oil while cooking. Do you want to know what’s the most convenient? The large loop handle on the steak pan’s side provides a better grip and ensures that the hot steak pan does not fall from your hands while cooking or serving food.

Washing up this Le Creuset steak pan is the easiest as you have to either load it up in the dishwasher or else wash it manually with soap and a sponge.

Pros
  • Requires little oil
  • Striking color
  • Large loop handle
  • Dishwasher safe
Cons
  • Small diameter size

Best Pan for Steak Reviews – The Ultimate Buying Guide

Have you seen how Lodge has made its place in the market by offering an all-in-one steak pan that has it all from the material, color, and coating to the affordable pricing? But are you satisfied with the Le Creuset pre-seasoned steak pan, which has the best modern design available in the market and is known to be versatile?

And what about the eco-friendly Cuisinart Square Grill pan, which is made from recycled materials and soy ink? Do you feel that you should contribute to saving the environment? With various varieties and competition between different brands, choosing the best frying pan for grilling steak can become quite challenging. 

What’s the worth? There’s no need for you to worry as we have got you covered. You won’t have a hard time figuring out when you finally have to choose the best cast iron pan for steak after reading our detailed buying guide we have written just for you.

Pan size

Searching for a suitable steak pan size along with affordability can be a time-consuming task. Choosing a large steak pan has its benefits as you are able to cook more quantity of food and have more space for bigger pieces of steak.

However, if you live alone or do not use a steak pan daily, you can also opt for a small or a round steak pan as it will be enough to fulfill your requirements quickly.

Material

A steak pan should be manufactured from high-quality and durable material. This way, your steak pan will last a long time, and there will be reduced wear and tear.

Most of the best frying pans for steak either include Cast Iron or Cast Aluminum. These materials are well-known and appreciated by everyone for providing even heating to the steak while it is being cooked.

Eco-Friendly

Are you a person who would like to contribute to an eco-friendly environment by purchasing a steak pan that has been made from recycled material?

If yes, you have the Cuisinart Square Grill Pan option, which is made from 100% recycled material along with its handle. Despite being manufactured by recycled material, it is one of the best performing steak pans.

Price

Deciding the price range you want to go for is necessary if you have a fixed budget and only invest a specific amount. If you’re looking for options for the best pan for steak cooking that too in a particular range, there’s no need to worry as we have provided you with plenty of options which you can choose from.

There’s no need to panic as low prices do not mean that the quality and the longevity of the steak pan will be compromised.

Non-stick coating

Having a non-stick coating on the interior of your steak pan is a must-have as it not only distributes heat evenly while cooking but also retains heat for a certain period of time after the heat has been turned off. This ensures that your food will remain warm, and you won’t have to face the hassle of heating it again.

Color

Most of the time, steak pans are usually available in neutral dark colors such as grey, black or silver.

However, if you prefer steak pans that are colorful and light up your kitchen, you can check out steak pans by Le Creuset as they deliver a range of color options, including striking colors such as Flame and Marseille.

Chemical-free  

Most of the brands mentioned in the list above offer a steak pan free from PFOA and other chemicals. Chemical-free steak pans encourage you to eat a healthy low-fat diet, and also, such steak pans require very little or no oil while cooking.

Frequently Asked Questions  

  • Is it best to put a steak in the freezer for 20 minutes before putting it in the pan to fry?

According to steak lovers’ expert opinion, cooking a steak directly from the freezer without thawing it taste more delicious. Not only that, but a frozen steak loses less moisture and cooks evenly without leaving some parts raw.

  • What type of pan is best for steak? 

It is preferable that you opt for a cast iron or a cast aluminum pan to cook steak as both of these pans can reach a very high heat level and also retain the heat, which is essential for you to cook the steak evenly.

  • What cut of steak is best for pan frying?  

If you are cooking on a stovetop, it is recommended that you choose boneless steaks, which are between one and one-and-a-half inches thick. Thicker cuts like New York Strip steak or boneless rib-eye also work fine.

  • What is best for frying steak in an aluminum fry pan or a stainless steel fry pan?

An Aluminum fry pan heats up faster, is safer, and holds against higher temperatures. It also features a non-stick coating and does not contain harmful chemicals.

On the other hand, a Stainless Steel fry pan is durable and compatible with metal surfaces. It has high heat retention and is versatile, meaning it can be used for various purposes such as frying, cooking, sauteing, and boiling.

The Bottom Line

Getting the best pan for steak will help you enjoy your meals with an added flavor, low-fat, healthy food, and aesthetic grill marks on your evenly cooked steak. The steak pans, which are a part of our list, have been selected with much care and consideration. They not only offer excellent and unique features but are also budget-friendly, so you don’t have to think much before purchasing them.

We have given detailed reviews on the top seven picks, but you have to make the final choice. You should go through all the features, and the details given, and decide which features act as a deal-breaker for you and eliminate those.

But, if you’re still confused, here’s our recommendation, the Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet, which offers the best features overall in terms of durability, affordability, and modern features. Now, what are you waiting for? You should go and get your steak pan now without further delay.

Leave a Comment