9 Best Yogurt Makers We’ve Tested

The Winner is the Euro Cuisine YM80 Yogurt Maker, which offers everything you need.

best yogurt makers

Tested And Approved: We liked Euro Cuisine YM80 Yogurt Maker for its features and affordability. It provides extra options to let you control the final product. Making any type of yogurt makes it a top performer among yogurt makers. However, if you want a diverse and multi-option yogurt maker, you should be looking for Instant Pot Duo yogurt maker. Its extraordinary automatic functioning makes it a perfect choice for anyone who likes to automate the process.

There is no replacement for homemade food’s taste, hygiene, or health benefits. Processed foods have become a vital part of our lives, but they cannot replace homemade food in this regard. One such example is yogurt which we see as healthy when consumed, but you may have no idea what ingredients the packaged yogurt carries. It is where the best yogurt maker comes in handy.

Yogurt makers enable you to make various yogurts while giving you a healthy dose without fearing unhealthy ingredients. You can prepare Greek yogurt or regular yogurt without having to make any extra effort. Only you must invest in a good quality yogurt maker to get fresh yogurt without spending high on store-bought yogurt. These yogurt makers enable you to automate the process, making them practical even if you have a busy schedule.

You may need assistance when buying the yogurt maker as plenty of good options are available. But if it is your first time purchasing a yogurt maker, you may be confused about the selection and find it challenging to buy a good one. Don’t worry; I have done the work for you and listed the best yogurt makers you can buy to make healthy and nutritious yogurt at home. The buying guide will enable you to make the right decision, and don’t forget to check my recommendation if you want to have an expert opinion. Let’s get started!

What to Look for When Buying the Best Yogurt Maker?

Several considerations are must to keep in mind when buying the yogurt maker. Each person’s preference can differ according to their requirements, but the criteria for selecting the best yogurt maker remain the same. Have a look at these considerations!

  • The size of the yogurt maker is crucial and, foremost, the most important thing you must consider when buying one. You must first figure out how much serving you need for the family and how much space you have on the countertop to store the yogurt makers. Some yogurt makers are larger, while some have small containers. Choose the option that fits your preference and feels convenient.
  • The mode of operation of the yogurt maker is the second most important consideration you may want to investigate when buying. Electric yogurt makers are versatile and provide more options than non-electric yogurt. You can have options like timers, LED display, and settings for hardness on the electric yogurt maker. If these are not your preference, you may opt for the non-electric yogurt makers.
  • Having extra features at your disposal is always helpful whenever buying the yogurt maker. You may look for the yogurt maker with extra bells and whistles. Many yogurt makers offer options like timers and auto-shutoff that may be handy for most users. You may opt for the adjustable temperature to get the right consistency. It’s all about what you prefer and may find helpful when buying the yogurt maker.
  • Yogurt preparation time is one of the primary concerns when buying a yogurt maker. It can range between four to eight hours, depending on the model you purchase. It also depends on the thickness and consistency you would like for the yogurt. Choose the yogurt maker with an adjustable preparation time to get the desired flavor you crave for the serving.
  • These days, BPA Free plastic is the way to buy kitchen gadgets. Having a yogurt maker with this chemical can seriously affect overall health. I have listed the 9 best BPA-free yogurt makers, so you won’t have to worry about consuming dangerous chemicals in your food.

Our Top Picks

  1. Euro Cuisine YM80 Yogurt Maker
  2. Instant Pot Duo Yogurt Maker
  3. Euro Cuisine YMX650 Automatic Digital Yogurt Maker
  4. Euro Cuisine YM460 Greek Yogurt Maker
  5. Euro Cuisine GY50 Greek Yogurt Maker
  6. Dash Greek Yogurt Maker with LCD Display
  7. Bear Yogurt Maker
  8. Proctor Silex Yogurt Maker 86300
  9. Country Trading Stainless Steel Yoghurt Maker

Best Yogurt Makers You Can Buy in 2022

Euro Cuisine YM80

Euro Cuisine YM80 Yogurt Maker

Features

  • Dishwasher Friendly
  • Safe Materials
  • Intuitive Timer

What We Like

  • The jars are individually portioned
  • Time and dials are intuitive
  • Can serve seven types of yogurt at a time
  • Up to 42-ounce yogurt volume

What We Don’t Like

  • Lacks automatic shutdown
  • No temperature adjustment

Euro Cuisine YM80 Yogurt Maker is an exceptional choice for being affordable and providing performance that you can get on the most expensive yogurt makers. It is an electric yogurt maker that has the capacity for seven glass containers so that you can make different types of yogurt separately. The 42-ounce capacity and compact body make it ideal for any countertop.

The front of the Euro Cuisine has a control that lets your turn it on and off it. The indicator light is also bound to the switch so you can know when the machine is working. The markings on the side of the body compensate for the absence of the digital display. It lets you know about the progress of the yogurt fermentation, and you can adjust the timing for making the yogurt with the consistency you want.

The design of the YM80 is not much complex as you can throw the ingredients and wait for the process to complete. You only have to set the timer, and voila, the serving of fresh yogurt awaits you. The Euro Cuisine Yogurt maker has six jars for the versatility of yogurt. It lets you make several types of yogurt at once and serve your family members according to the type of yogurt they like the most.

During the tests, I loved the ease of use and design of Euro Cuisine YM80 yogurt makers. The taste feels fresh and better than most brands offering packaged yogurt in the superstores. I also liked the separate partition for the yogurt of different types and easy-to-grab glass containers. You can test and make seven types of yogurt at once separately in these glass jars. One thing I must appreciate about Euro Cuisine YM80 is its ability to expand the capacity as you can buy additional jars with an expansion rack making them 14 in total.

Although the Euro Cuisine YM80 is ideal for yogurt making, it lacks the most important and practical component. Having missed the auto shutoff feature, you must manually monitor the process using the numbering and front timer. You must remain close to the yogurt maker to turn it off once it is ready.

The overall operation and utility of the Euro Cuisine YM80 are excellent. Seven jars are available along the purchase with lids to make the yogurt extra delicious. You don’t have to hassle much for separating and making the yogurt, as you can serve each family member the yogurt of their choice. Although it is not complex, it still does the job effortlessly.

Related: Best Keto Yogurts for Keto Diet.


Instant Pot Duo Yogurt Maker

Instant Pot Duo Yogurt Maker

Features

  • Seven in-one functionality
  • Overheat protection and safe locking lid
  • Versatile inner pot
  • One touch cooking

What We Like

  • Multipurpose for kitchen use
  • The auto yogurt function is highly effective
  • The build quality is premium
  • Super easy to clean

What We Don’t Like

  • The countertop footprint takes a lot of space
  • It requires some time to be proper functioning
  • The cord is a bit short

Nothing beats Instant Pot Duo and Yogurt Maker if you prefer multifunctional kitchen appliances. It is a perfect choice, especially for yogurt making, due to its automatic mechanism. It combines seven different appliances: a slow cooker, pressure cooker, warmer, steamer, rice cooker, saute pan, and yogurt maker. However, the combination is ideal for various needs, but it is expensive.

The design of the Instant Pot Duo yogurt maker is simple yet elegant. It features a touch control on the front to give you complete command of the options. The display is large enough to give feedback on what’s happening inside the pot. You can set the pressure high or low using the touch control on display. It comes included with the steam rack to let you have a diverse set of options.

The Instant Pot Duo yogurt maker is your one-stop for making the perfect yogurt for serving. It has preprogrammed yogurt button to let you make delicious yogurt. You only need to start the process and put the milk inside the pot. Choosing the yogurt setting is like a breeze; you will get the desired serving within 8 to 12 hours, depending on your preferences.

While testing, I found the automatic yogurt function helpful. The process is the same, as you don’t have to tweak the temperature and timer settings every time. The one-touch operation is intuitive and lets me operate the yogurt maker without hassle. The diverse set of cooking tools has unique appeal as it lets you cook several other dishes without buying separate appliances, which is a plus point.

There is no downside when using the yogurt maker in general. However, if you want to use the cooker function, you must be careful when releasing the pressure valve. If you are not used to pressuring cooking, it may not be an easy grab for very few first attempts. You can burn your hand in a try to open the usual way. The steam release valve design is unsuitable for pressure releasing as a side lever would be a better option.

The Instant Pot Duo Yogurt Maker is notable for making homemade yogurt. It has many other cooking options to let you have fun while cooking. The larger display and easy-to-use touch controls are enough to rank it top for the best yogurt maker. However, you may look for other options if your only purpose is to make yogurt and you don’t want additional tools.


Euro Cuisine YMX650

Euro Cuisine YMX650 Automatic Digital Yogurt Maker

Features

  • Seven glass jars with date setting lid
  • 15 hours simple timer
  • Automatic shutdown
  • BPA free materials

What We Like

  • It can serve 42 ounces of yogurt in one go
  • The auto temperature and shutdown are handy
  • Can make several flavors at once
  • Dishwasher safe

What We Don’t Like

  • Dealing with the seven jars can be a hassle in cleaning
  • Lids are not secured
  • The seals on the lids are not airtight

Who said that variety has to be complicated? The Euro Cuisine YMX650 Digital Automatic Yogurt Maker offers a simple solution to having a range of flavors in your homemade yogurt. Rather than one big container, this yogurt machine comes with seven small glass jars. Owing to the seven jars, it lets you mix and store different flavors beforehand and provide you eat healthy yogurt.

This yogurt maker might not have a lot of extra features, but it does come with some features that make yogurt-making easier. For example, the front of the machine has a timer display with high visibility, so you can tell at a glance how many hours are left until your yogurt prepares. It is always a great convenience at your end because you don’t want to check for completion manually.

The machine will come with a timer and an alarm to let you know when your yogurt gets done so that you won’t have to worry about forgetting it. It is an excellent feature for people who tend to forget things or who are always busy. There are also many other quality-of-life features, such as choosing how long you want your yogurt to be made.

The Euro Cuisine YMX650 showed fantastic performance during the testing period. It only has to preheat the milk equivalent to the capacity of the jars and then put it into them. The only care requires when pouring the milk is to add flavors in a way that they don’t mix up in the same jar.

After setting up the jars inside the Euro Cuisine YMX650, the only thing that requires adjustment is the upper lid. I didn’t need to set up the temperature and shutdown timer due to the presence of 15 hours auto timer. The timer also takes the responsibility of keeping an eye on the yogurt maker away as you don’t need to monitor it after you set the timer. The LED light indicator is a great way to let you know when you need to transfer the prepared yogurt for serving.

The only thing I would like to see improved in the Euro Cuisine YMX650 is the quality of the jar lids. They have exceptional build quality at this price but are not secure. They can spill the yogurt or milk when not handled carefully.

The YMX650 is not only reliable, but it’s also one of the most affordable electric yogurt makers on the market. It’s certainly got a reputation as the best yogurt maker, and for a good reason. With all of its features and its low price tag, it’s an excellent value for your money.


Euro Cuisine YM460

Euro Cuisine YM460 Greek Yogurt Maker

Features

  • Stainless steel thermometer
  • BPA free material
  • Timer marks

What We Like

  • It comes with a thermometer for a temperature check
  • The compact design supports relatively decent quantities
  • Easy to operate
  • Makes tasty yogurt

What We Don’t Like

  • The lids do not stay properly on the jar
  • It has a heating element on the bottom
  • Need careful handling when taking the yogurt out

Nothing beats Euro Cuisine YM460 Greek Yogurt Maker if you want to buy a yogurt maker with a thermometer and compact design. It has a simple design that ditches out touch controls or an LCD screen that most other yogurt makers follow. The inside has jar glass to make the serving as healthy as possible as it doesn’t have any BPA plastic involved in yogurt making.

If you have limited counter space and don’t want to clutter things more on the countertop, the Euro Cuisine YM460 is ideal. Although it has a small and compact body, it packs features that you won’t get from other competitors. The glass jar can fit snugly inside the body, and you can monitor the fermentation progress throughout the process.

The 2 quarts of yogurt quantity equates to the 8 cups of yogurt for the whole family serving. It offers the same amount of yogurt you can get in bulkier and heavy-duty yogurt makers. The stainless steel thermometer comes in handy to control the temperature.

The performance of the Euro Cuisine YM460 is not any less than the manufacturer advertised. We analyzed it against competitors during our tests, which surprisingly performed more than our expectations. We liked how you have control over the cooking due to the lack of auto shutoff, as you can cut the yogurt, making time according to your preference.

Like the Euro Cuisine YMX650 Automatic Digital Yogurt Maker, the Euro Cuisine YM460 has an issue with the lid. The lids are not as secure as you would expect from a product that involves food handling. The lid on the glass jar is slightly loose, but not to the extent that you have to worry about spills every time you make the yogurt.

Overall, Euro Cuisine YM460 Greek Yogurt Maker is the ultimate choice if you want freshly made and healthy yogurt for the family. It has a compact, minimalistic design that blends well with the kitchen layout. Furthermore, three color choices perk things up: green, red, and white.


Euro Cuisine GY50

Euro Cuisine GY50 Greek Yogurt Maker

Features

  • Straightforward to use
  • BPA Free material
  • Two quarts capacity

What We Like

  • It does not require any electricity
  • It can make Greek and other yogurts
  • The manual instructions are clear
  • Cleaning does not involve any hassle

What We Don’t Like

  • Not dishwasher safe
  • The filter mesh does seem fragile
  • Requires experience to operate

Euro Cuisine’s GY50 Greek Yogurt Maker is an appliance that allows you to make Greek yogurt at home within a few hours. You can place it inside your fridge, which means you don’t have to do anything else to make homemade Greek yogurt other than putting the yogurt into the maker and waiting a few hours. It can hold up to two quarts of yogurt, so it’s a time-saver if you want to make large batches of Greek yogurt.

The build quality of the Euro Cuisine GY50 yogurt maker is outstanding. It has entirely plastic construction. For a health-conscious person, plastic is not the best material for kitchen appliances but having BPA-free plastic is an entirely different scenario. The material used in the GY50 construction is high-quality plastic with no BPA inclusion, making it the perfect choice for making fresh and healthy yogurt.

The Euro Cuisine GY50 Greek Yogurt Maker is more than just a kitchen appliance; it’s a work of art. With its sleek design and innovative functionality, the Euro Cuisine GY50 Greek Yogurt Maker will last a long time. Not to mention, it promotes healthy cooking in a modern way – something that we can all get behind!

Say goodbye to ancient yogurt-making techniques with the Euro Cuisine GY50 Greek Yogurt Maker. This yogurt maker can filter the liquid for you to achieve the Greek yogurt consistency you desire. No more paper bags or cheesecloths are needed.

Due to the analog operation, you cannot automate the yogurt-making process. If you are new to yogurt making, finding a balance where the yogurt’s consistency and taste match your flavor may be slightly challenging. If you are an expert and have no issue monitoring the whole yogurt-making process, the lack of electric functionality does not matter much!

Overall, Euro Cuisine is an excellent investment for making quality yogurt. The container is spacious, making ample quantities of yogurt for large servings. You can preserve the freshness of the yogurt by keeping the container in the refrigerator. Besides the analog operation, no such drawbacks concerning you regarding the purchase decision.


Dash Greek Yogurt Maker with LCD Display

Dash Greek Yogurt Maker

Features

  • Stainer basket
  • Electric power
  • 4 cups yogurt

What We Like

  • Highest build quality
  • Effortless cleaning
  • It does not take up much space
  • Affordable pricing

What We Don’t Like

  • No adjustable temperature gauge
  • Only suitable for Greek yogurt
  • Less quantity

The Dash Greek yogurt maker is an excellent choice for anyone who loves Greek yogurt. It’s easy to use and affordable, especially considering how much you’d spend on Greek yogurt at the store. Greek yogurt is strained to remove water, giving it its thick, creamy consistency. Dash yogurt maker excels in this regard.

The design of the Dash Greek Yogurt Maker is simple, featuring a start and stop button on the front. You can use the buttons to set the total cooking time of the yogurt. Although the process and design may look similar, the included filter makes the difference. It allows for the removal of extra water, giving the yogurt a thick consistency like Greek yogurt.

The base of this model can fit all of the accessories that come with it, which is perfect if you’re looking to save some cabinet space. Plus, its design is pleasing to the eye. And if you’re worried about cleanup, don’t be – this model is dishwasher safe.

Thanks to the Yogurt Maker, making Greek yogurt is now easy. Plus, with the electric function that controls the right temperature, you won’t have to spend much time preparing ingredients. All you have to do is wait for about 8-12 hours, and you’ll be able to enjoy the soft and creamy Greek yogurt.

The total quantity that the Greek yogurt maker will yield is around a quart and a half. So, depending on how many people you are trying to make Greek yogurt for, you may need to choose a bigger model. However, if you’re the only one eating Greek yogurt in your household, this specific yogurt maker will do the job just fine.

Ditch your old, hard-to-operate yogurt maker for this new and improved Greek yogurt maker. It is easy to use and clean–plus, you can make yogurt several times a week with it. You can buy it if you want a simple yogurt maker that makes delicious and fresh Greek yogurt anytime.


Bear Yogurt Maker

Bear Yogurt Maker

Features

  • Strainer component
  • Advanced timer settings
  • Food friendly materials

What We Like

  • The material is durable and safe
  • It is time-saving
  • Temperature control is precise
  • Usage is convenient

What We Don’t Like

  • It is a bit on the expensive side
  • Requires to preheat before putting in the machine
  • Lacks directions to use for recipe

The Bear Yogurt Maker is an excellent addition to the best yogurt maker list that surely deserves top rank among the competitors. It boasts a trendy design bundled with excellent performance. You don’t want to miss out on this yogurt maker as it has a set of cool electric and digital features. Timer settings and LED indicators come standard with the Bear yogurt maker, which helps automate the whole process.

Bear yogurt maker carries a traditional design as you can see a button on the front to control the functions. You get complete control over the final product and can monitor the whole yogurt-making process. The display is large enough to be visible from a range allowing you to observe the temperature. It is a great way to know the current temperature in the fermenting process.

The design alone is not a notable feature of the Bear Greek Yogurt makers as it has other aspects worth mentioning regarding build quality. The BPA-free plastic material used in the construction of this yogurt maker makes it suitable for food-grade use. The bucket inside the main body is spacious and does not contaminate the food keeping the original taste alive.

The ability to make regular and Greek yogurt is appreciable for the Bear yogurt maker. Although it lacks a strainer for making Greek yogurt, it still functions well. You have to keep track of heating as regular yogurt requires 8 hours, while Greek yogurt requires you to heat it for at least 10 hours.

Another feature that boasts shows the true potential of the Bear yogurt maker is its ability to remain versatile. You can ferment other food items like cheese using the yogurt maker. You must follow the recipe to make the cheese, which requires you to heat and ferment at 140 degrees for six hours to make the final product.

Besides being expensive, the Bear Yogurt Maker does not have much to complain about. One thing that needs improvement is the dedicated manual for instructions and recipes. If you are new to yogurt making, you may require additional help for operating and understating the functionality which lacks here.

The Bear Greek Yogurt Maker is an ultimate choice for the people concerned, having a large display and LED indicator for monitoring fermentation progress. It costs slightly more than the analog yogurt maker but is worth every penny if build quality and functionality are the primary concern.


Proctor Silex 86300

Proctor Silex Yogurt Maker 86300

Features

  • Convenient storage
  • Countertop friendly
  • Digital controls

What We Like

  • The storage is airtight
  • The controls are digital and convenient
  • Cleaning and maintenance are easy
  • It comes included with a recipe

What We Don’t Like

  • No proper space for the container to lift
  • Clips are prone to wear and tear
  • Not best for large servings

Proctor Silex 86300 is the best yogurt maker for regular and Greek yogurt as it supports preparation and manufacturing. It is convenient to use due to the large display, touch controls, and instructions manual that come along with the purchase. Having airtight storage gives you the utility of storage inside the fridge for keeping the yogurt fresh for long.

Although the Proctor Silex 86300 yogurt maker looks simple, it has a modern outlook. The body is compact and doesn’t take much space on the countertop. You can operate it with the help of the touch control on the upper side and the LCD. Having a clear sight of the temperature and timer is helpful for yogurt with good consistency.

The best of Proctor Silex 86300 is how easily it operates. Everything is clear and understandable. You only need to plug the switch and set the timer on the yogurt maker. It will take the desired time and make the yogurt. For Greek yogurt, the cooking time is slightly longer, and you must go nearly 14 hours to achieve proper consistency and delicious taste.

During testing, I felt that the yogurt maker need some improvement in the utility department. It can use another container for making a large batch of yogurt. This way, it can prepare a batch and store it in the refrigerator, and then the second container can yield another batch. However, if your needs are only specific to the quantity of one container, the Proctor Silex is the best choice for most people.

Overall, the Proctor Silex 86300 perfectly fits the budget while being able to make both regular and Greek yogurt. It has a simple yet intuitive design that can help you operate smoothly without having to take guidelines from any manual. It can make yogurt for a small family but may need extra preparation time for serving large gatherings.


Country Trading Stainless Steel Yoghurt Maker

Country Trading Stainless Steel Yoghurt Maker

Features

  • Heavy-duty glass jar
  • Complete recipe book
  • Stainless steel lid
  • Double walled insulation

What We Like

  • Elegant and minimalistic design
  • Free from plastic materials
  • High-grade stainless steel construction
  • No electricity required
  • Thick and consistent yogurt

What We Don’t Like

  • The jar doesn’t contain heat
  • Expensive than similar options
  • The preparation needs more time

The Country Trading Co. yogurt maker is an excellent appliance for anyone who loves yogurt but doesn’t want to deal with the hassle of electronic yogurt makers. This simple and compact model has no timers, which could increase the risk of overheating. With this yogurt maker, you can make any flavor or texture of yogurt that you want, and the quality stainless steel and glass components make it a durable appliance.

The Country Trading Stainless Steel Yogurt Maker offers versatility. The operation, cleaning, and usage are straightforward. It has a simple and elegant design that takes up small space on the countertop. Glass jar ensures plastic-free and healthy yogurt, while the steel lid at the top keeps it airtight for usage. You can expect the yogurt to be fresh and free from sourness due to the tightly closed lid and glass jar.

The yogurt maker is also suitable for a variety of other things, like making soft cheese, sour cream, and lactose-free yogurt. You can also use it to make cultured butter and other fermented foods. With Country Trading yogurt maker, you can control the whole process and modify it according to the needs. The safety mechanism is strong enough to give you a worry-free experience from overheating.

I have carried out the testing and analyzed the whole yogurt-making process. Its stainless steel container can contain the heated milk required for making yogurt. I only have to heat the milk to the required temperature and add the starter to make the perfect jar of a fresh and healthy dose of yogurt.

It only takes eight hours to complete the fermentation process, which is standard for most yogurt makers. The only treatment it requires after the fermentation is cooling the yogurt to the desired temperature. For this purpose, you can place the prepared yogurt into the fridge and enjoy every bite of freshly prepared yogurt at home.

One thing I found challenging in Trading Country Yogurt Maker is its inability to contain the heat. The jar is perfect for making yogurt, but if you have a cold temperature outside, you may find it challenging to maintain the temperature required for yogurt making. However, you can manage it by placing the yogurt maker in a controlled environment.

The Country Trading Yogurt Maker is a popular choice among yogurt lovers who want a consistent way of making yogurt according to their recipe. It doesn’t matter what type of yogurt you want to make, as it can do it all for you. Another plus is that it doesn’t require electricity to operate, unlike other yogurt makers, which tend to overheat.


How We Tested?

When determining the best yogurt maker among several options, we have tested them against certain factors and characteristics. Based on those rankings, we have compiled this list of top yogurt makers you can buy for the money. These considerations include preparation time, safety, controls, mode of operation, and overall capacity.

The above list contains the yogurt makers that are BPA-free and free from any toxic material that can prove unhealthy. We have included electric and non-electric yogurt makers for convenience selection as buyers have diverse usage depending on their preferences.

Furthermore, the list also clearly has diverse size and capacity options. It has yogurt makers suitable for a single serving and some for family or multiple servings. The preparation time is another aspect that we have considered when selecting these yogurt makers. Adjusting the time can let you prepare any yogurt type with perfect consistency. For more information on how we tested, check out our testing methodology.

Why Trust TheLadyChef

At TheLadyChef, we have a team of experts who know all about kitchen accessories. They put products to the test and then write in-depth reviews. We follow the same process for the yogurt maker, ensuring that it meets all of our set criteria. We want our readers to have the best information possible before purchasing. TheLadyChef has quickly become the go-to source for kitchen accessory reviews and recipes with thousands of happy readers.

Adalynn Ward
Hello!! My name is Adalynn I love to eat, travel, and eat some more! I am married to the man of my dreams and have a beautiful little girl whose smiles can brighten anyone’s day!